Craig Mc Kinnon, Jesse Beck and Jonathan Novack returned in the first season of Bachelor Pad, finished in 16th/17th, 7th/8th and 14th/15th.
Chris Lambton and Ty Brown offered the roles to be selected as the next bachelor for the fifteenth season of The Bachelor but they turned down the offer due to work obligations. continued their bickering about who is the better match for Ali.
They traveled to Times Square where they saw an electronic billboard message referring to the concrete jungle. Prior to the start of the date, the remaining bachelors wrote a love poem in Icelandic and only one of them would be chosen for the date. Then, he asked Ali's dad to give him permission to marry Ali. also had a close connection with Ali's family and they had a lot in common as they are both from Massachusetts. They jet-skied on a lagoon and spent a night at a beach house (dubbed as "Mi Casa" by Roberto).
They auditioned for the musical play, The Lion King. and Ali went to a private concert featuring Joshua Radin along with the Harlem Boys choir. Kirk was chosen, and he and Ali picked up matching fair isle sweaters. Group: Frank, Chris N., Chris L., Craig R., Ty and Roberto. Roberto for the first round; the final round was Craig R. The day before the rose ceremony, Ali told Chris L.
Ali was really upset to learn about Justin's behavior and he left the show. They took part in an oil wrestling on Rumeli Fortress with professional oil wrestlers. At the rose ceremony, Roberto declared that he was in love with Ali and proposed to her. Frank was supposed to come on the show, but did not come last minute. reunite since Chris L.'s emotional leave before the rose ceremony, and the two have talked while Chris L. Roberto talked with Chris Harrison on his post-engagement with Ali and the couple discussed their post-show plans, including their move to San Diego which Roberto could start on his life and his new job there.
Justin Rego, Kasey Kahl and Kirk De Windt returned in the second season of Bachelor Pad, finished in 17th/18th, 5th/6th and 7th/8th. Ali and Jesse flew in a private jet to Las Vegas, Nevada for a fancy dinner and private concert with Jamie Callum, one of Ali's favorite artists. Original airdate: June 7, 2010 One-on-one: Roberto.
In 2015, De Windt returned to compete for the third time in the second season of Bachelor in Paradise and finished in 9th/10th. Ali and Roberto go on a helicopter ride over Los Angeles and land on the roof of a 20-story building. Kirk was eliminated and Frank received the last rose. Roberto and Ali went to a heart-shaped island for their date.
Derrick, Derek, Jason, Jay, John N., Kyle, Phil and Tyler M. Ali took the guys to Malibu Beach to do a photo shoot for a "celebrity" calendar charity project. After dinner, Ali and Roberto cuddle in the candlelight. Justin walked in on all the guys talking about him and got upset. and Ali took a moped ride and went to a winery on the outskirts of Lisbon. Ali came to Frank's villa and they talked about his feelings for his ex-girlfriend.Group: John C., Chris N., Kirk, Jonathon, Craig R., Jesse, Frank, Justin, and Chris L. Ali tells Roberto that Justin visited her at her house and he tells the guys. Kasey and Ali took a helicopter tour of New York City and stopped at American Museum of Natural History. They took a helicopter ride and had a tour of a medieval castle, where they ate dinner. Kirk and Ali ride a horse and carriage to a castle. Original airdate: July 12, 2010 Roberto and Ali traveled to a baseball stadium in his hometown of Tampa, Florida. He left before the rose ceremony, leaving Ali heartbroken in tears.